A high court in Japan has rejected a claim by an adult entertainment business operator that the sex-related industry should also be eligible for the state subsidies for firms impacted by the coronavirus pandemic.
The Tokyo High Court on Thursday upheld the lower court ruling that it is not unconstitutional to exclude sex-related businesses from the relief funding.
The operator in western Japan sought the subsidies and compensation in the lawsuit. It argued that the exclusion is occupational discrimination and violates the constitutional guarantee of equality under the law.
Presiding Judge Matsumoto Toshiyuki of the high court said it is reasonable for the government to decide that it would be difficult to gain public understanding if the industry became eligible for its subsidies.
Matsumoto said that even though people's values of sex and gender have become diversified, it is still considered inappropriate to publicly acknowledge sex-related businesses.
The district court ruling said earlier that the characteristics of the industry run counter to the moral consciousness of most people, and it is therefore reasonable to treat it differently from others.
The Tokyo High Court on Thursday upheld the lower court ruling that it is not unconstitutional to exclude sex-related businesses from the relief funding.
The operator in western Japan sought the subsidies and compensation in the lawsuit. It argued that the exclusion is occupational discrimination and violates the constitutional guarantee of equality under the law.
Presiding Judge Matsumoto Toshiyuki of the high court said it is reasonable for the government to decide that it would be difficult to gain public understanding if the industry became eligible for its subsidies.
Matsumoto said that even though people's values of sex and gender have become diversified, it is still considered inappropriate to publicly acknowledge sex-related businesses.
The district court ruling said earlier that the characteristics of the industry run counter to the moral consciousness of most people, and it is therefore reasonable to treat it differently from others.
Similar Readings (5 items)
Top court upholds denial of COVID subsidies to sex industry businesses
Japan's Supreme Court rejects demand for reversal of pension cut
Japan's Supreme Court: Restroom restrictions for trans woman illegal
Japan allows individuals to decide whether to wear anti-coronavirus masks
Japanese government's position over wartime labor issue
Summary
Japan's High Court upholds decision to exclude adult entertainment industry from COVID-19 subsidies, citing moral consciousness and public understanding. The court dismissed a claim of occupational discrimination, stating that it is reasonable for the government to exclude sex-related businesses
Statistics
179
Words1
Read CountDetails
ID: f8905803-738b-49ee-a130-dfd21cf20d68
Category ID: nhk
URL: https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/news/20231005_33/
Date: Oct. 5, 2023
Created: 2023/10/06 07:21
Updated: 2025/12/08 22:53
Last Read: 2023/10/06 07:49